Code examples forum.

I have seen an increase in users posting code and asking for ratings because they believe their code is good. To me this seems like an attempt to show off rather than help or seek help. This is not the purpose of dev-archive.

Do you, Brad or Andreas, this it would be a good idea to have a forum for users to post their source codes that they want to show off and make that no rating and no post count just like the chit-chat forum?
[441 byte] By [PeejAvery] at [2007-11-19 18:30:56]
# 1 Re: Code examples forum.
VBF has the CodeBank that gets added to manually, by a Moderator. Lots of ratings are given to good code. I can see adding the same thing here, but wouldn't agree that it be sealed from ratings.
I've seen people asking for points recently, and I know that it isn't allowed. Rather than nix them for NEGATIVE points, I've just let them slide. That would be one way to show them that what they did was wrong, though.
dglienna at 2007-11-10 3:36:07 >
# 2 Re: Code examples forum.
I do not give negative ratings but at the same time I do not believe that a person who is posting code to show off should receive ratings.

I believe that a person who deserves ratings are those who are helping others not just showing off. People do post code for the soul purpose of gaining ratings and this is not helpful.

dev-archive exists as a tool to teach, showing off is not teaching and often can be discouraging to others.

I will only rate those who solve other problems or do their best with what they are given when attempting to serve others.
PeejAvery at 2007-11-10 3:37:09 >
# 3 Re: Code examples forum.
Probably they have a good intention to share their work but just that they are not aware of the proper channel. CG is already accomodating these people as long as they put in a little more time to write an article or FAQ. If I were to see these postings, I would recommend them doing so. As long as it got approved by the reviewing panel here, it will be published. In this way, it better served the community instead of causing misunderstanding.
Kheun at 2007-11-10 3:38:10 >
# 4 Re: Code examples forum.
I've downloaded, edited, and uploaded lots of examples that do specfic things.
I was just linking to my original post for others, and even after removing the duplicates, I had 4 pages (at 200 lines per page) of my attachments.
Now I don't have access to my attachments on VBF, so I guess I'll have to upload them again.
I guess JM can afford the disk space! I backed it up last night and it was over 5 gigs!
dglienna at 2007-11-10 3:39:16 >
# 5 Re: Code examples forum.
Well...we already got a Samples (http://www.dev-archive.com/cpp/misc/samples/) section on the main site. However, I am basically not in favor of simple code samples without a little bit explanation on what it does etc.

Thus, I am not sure whether I would like the idea of having such a forum.
Andreas Masur at 2007-11-10 3:40:18 >
# 6 Re: Code examples forum.
As already stated, we have an entire site focusing on coding examples (www.dev-archive.com). A person need only take a few minutes to write up an explanation of what is interesting about their code and submit it. We even have an online submission form (http://www.dev-archive.com/edit-article.php).

If they really don't want to write more than a few sentences, then they can suggest the samples suggestion; however, as Andreas commented, it is much, much better to add the extra text to an article to make the submission more valuable to others (and more valuable to list on your CV or resume ;) )

Brad!
Brad Jones at 2007-11-10 3:41:19 >
# 7 Re: Code examples forum.
I have seen an increase in users posting code and asking for ratings because they believe their code is good. To me this seems like an attempt to show off rather than help or seek help. This is not the purpose of dev-archive.
I notice you have a lot of concerns regarding the rating system. Some people ask for a rating when posting something, for instance code samples, others do it with every post, by putting it in their signature. (To me this is like putting in your signature "If you want to reply to this message, press the reply button".) Everybody is free to say anything, unless it violates the acceptable use policy.

Do you, Brad or Andreas, this it would be a good idea to have a forum for users to post their source codes that they want to show off and make that no rating and no post count just like the chit-chat forum?
Though the questions is addressed to Brad or Andreas, I want to say that I really don't see the need for such a forum. First, I do not agree with the idea that many people post code to show off. I would like to see some consistent evidence for that. And second, even if that was true, I don't see why those people would post in such a dedicated forum, when they can simply write and submit an article.
cilu at 2007-11-10 3:42:15 >
# 8 Re: Code examples forum.
I notice you have a lot of concerns regarding the rating system.
While the rating system can be nice it can also be a negative in many respects. There is no way it can be completely fair until everyone has the same mindset. I am not against it, nor am I for it. But I cannot stand abuse of it.

Though the questions is addressed to Brad or Andreas...
You do a lot here too so don't think as though you are jumping in. I welcome the ideas. I just know that Brad is the admin and Andreas is known by all. As well as you are. Sorry.

I really didn't think as though we needed it but kind of wanted to know what others though.

Concering people posting as show off, that is just the way it appeared to me. I was just thinking of an avenue allow this without flooding other forums where I like to answer and ask questions rather than post my accomplishments.

EDIT: I hope I am not portraying any discontentment or disgust for members. That is not my intention.
PeejAvery at 2007-11-10 3:43:18 >
# 9 Re: Code examples forum.
Concering people posting as show off, that is just the way it appeared to me. I was just thinking of an avenue allow this without flooding other forums where I like to answer and ask questions rather than post my accomplishments.
OK, I understand that this is how it appeasrs to you. But can you provide some examples?
cilu at 2007-11-10 3:44:19 >
# 10 Re: Code examples forum.
OK, I understand that this is how it appeasrs to you. But can you provide some examples?
Here ( http://www.dev-archive.com/forum/showthread.php?t=375184) is the one I just saw. I will have to look back and see if I can find the others. It has been a while on some.
PeejAvery at 2007-11-10 3:45:22 >
# 11 Re: Code examples forum.
Here (http://www.dev-archive.com/forum/showthread.php?t=375184) is the one I just saw. I will have to look back and see if I can find the others. It has been a while on some.
Well...I don't see a need for spending time on this...there have been and there will be always people coming to the site for just getting a high rating. Whether they use source code or anything else does basically not matter.

It is a simple fact that happens on every forum having any kind of rating, reputation or however, you want to call it. Thus, it's not really worthwile whether it is happening or not since the answer is already there... ;)
Andreas Masur at 2007-11-10 3:46:20 >
# 12 Re: Code examples forum.
Here (http://www.dev-archive.com/forum/showthread.php?t=375184) is the one I just saw. I will have to look back and see if I can find the others. It has been a while on some.
Yeah, well, ok. Good example. ;) However, with 1, 2, 10 cases you don't make a trend. There are thousands (or more) of people posting each month in the forums.
cilu at 2007-11-10 3:47:18 >
# 13 Re: Code examples forum.
Yeah, well, ok. Good example. ;) However, with 1, 2, 10 cases you don't make a trend. There are thousands (or more) of people posting each month in the forums.
That is why this was just to find out what others thought. I really don't care. I am just dropping the whole thing.
PeejAvery at 2007-11-10 3:48:17 >